“ First time to Plymouth and my man picked our place for lunch. From the moment we walked in we were awestruck by the craftsmanship of the interior. We were greeted by a warm and welcoming man who let us know to go upstairs. Once upstairs we were again greeted with such warmth, it felt as if we were regulars! Perach was our server and she was so nice. Our food was great! The atmosphere is outstanding! The people are so friendly they are hands down the coolest folks we have met in quite some time. I am begging my man to go back for Sunday night pizza!!! Thank you for a great experience:-) ”

“ Having been to Plymouth hundreds of times and never having visited this restaurant before is an immense tragedy. The atmosphere is so relaxing. The menu is small but it is due to the very smart move of making a few things very well rather than a huge menu of poorly executed dishes. The ginger carrot soup was extraordinary. A meal unto itself. The Cranberry Gobbler sandwich was delicious and the right level of hot. Great coleslaw and real root beer. I wholeheartedly recommend visiting the Yellow Deli if you visit Plymouth. ”

“ Impeccable operation. Squeaky clean and fantastic fresh food. Excellent customer service. Plenty of nooks and crannies to explore. ”

“ Lovely people, wonderful food, and a tremendously beautiful building. A wonderful experience. Looking forward to returning. ”

“ What a great experience. Very rarely do I get to say that. I was just walking down the road trying to locate a decent place for my 1 day trip to Plymouth and just happened to see this place with a very small "open 24 hrs" sign. Immediately peaked my interest because NOTHING is open 24 hrs anymore and it has to be good to stay open that often. I met some of the nicest people I came across in my week long trip to MA. From the second I was greeted at the door till the meal was done I was treated like a friend, and that I was valued. The menu was incredible with various choices including a fish sandwich that the staff catch and delicious tap root beer seeved in a frosted mug?! I realized after the waiter told me the workers all live together this place was different. I applaud their commitment to their lifestyle and faith, especially in today's world. I topped my dinner off with a carob brownie which I've never heard of before but throughougly enjoyed. I'm super impressed and wish this is what my typical dining experience was like. I see they have multiple locations which I will for sure be keeping my eye out for. I wish I could give it 6 stars. Thanks again. ”

“ I give this place five stars because my experience was mostly very pleasant, and because I was on a date with my boyfriend, we made the best of it. I did sense that there was something slightly off with the mood. The food was great, and the ambiance created a feeling of time travel. However, I couldn’t help but notice that most of the servers seemed very somber and, in a way, distant. Still, their service was exceptional—better than what I’ve experienced at many four-star restaurants. There’s something about visiting the Yellow Cafe that I can’t quite put into words. It felt as though the servers were human shells being moved by ghosts. As strange as that sounds, I have a deeper spiritual empathy for the places I visit, especially those with a history of injustice toward people with whom I share a cultural lineage. I can't help but think that the Wampanoag people have a presence in the land, a connection to the soil that nourishes the grains feeding the modern descendants of tourists who visit. I believe every patriot should visit the historic sites that shaped this country. Even during times of celebration, like Thanksgiving, it’s worth experiencing what it feels like to walk on the soil of America’s past. Take the time to spiritually connect with what you feel in these places, because you might be creating history yourself. ”

“ We recently visited this cute restaurant with a lot of character. I felt the place was quite comforting. The staff were some of the nicest people we ran into in Plymouth and so welcoming. I tried their Turkey Sandwich which was AMAZING! I also felt prices were a great deal! We love to return if we travel back again! I love sandwiches! ”

“ I've got to say, I've never been one to evangelize for a deli. I'm not necessarily the biggest fan of soup and I get my daily bread through means other than sandwiches. That being said the food here is so good it will make you see God. You also have to try their root beer in a frosted mug. It's a religious experience.The atmosphere in here is also wonderful. I can only imagine the small hands required for such precision woodworking. There is truly a youthful elegance to the craftsmanship. After eating here they've got a convert for life. ”